Rabbinic Reflection: Rabbi Yael Splansky
Report from Ottawa

As President of the Reform Rabbis of Canada (RROC), I’ve just returned from leading a delegation of fifteen colleagues for three days of advocacy work in Ottawa. We came from coast to coast, from Vancouver to Montreal, and many places in between. I’m proud that all four of your Holy Blossom rabbis were able to make this trip a priority.
The last RROC fly-in was four years ago, before October 7, 2023. Back then, we advocated on behalf of Israel, for Truth and Reconciliation with Indigenous Canadians, for refugees seeking safe haven from war-torn countries. Our focus had been on the needs of others. This time was altogether different. This time, our concerns were our own and for our own people. We came with stories of discrimination and violence, of slander and fear. We came with urgency. We came on your behalf.

Thanks to our good partners at CIJA (The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs), we met in different settings with many Conservative and Liberal Members of Parliament, including our congregant, Minister Evan Solomon, and Holy Blossom’s own MP, Leslie Church. We met with Israel’s Ambassador to Canada. We met with five representatives from National Security, CSIS, and Public Safety.
There was good news and bad news.
The security experts are redoubling their efforts to keep Jewish Canadians safe. We learned that three kinds of extremism – religious, political, and ideological – overlap in a Venn diagram, and Jews are the group placed at the centre, where all three circles converge. So Canadian security and intelligence services are coordinating their efforts like never before – both within Canada as well as within greater international networks. They are acutely aware of the threats and plots that have been thwarted.
The relationship between the government of Canada and the government of Israel is broken. Creating and strengthening economic alliances is Canada’s top priority. Last week, Prime Minister Carney hinted that things could improve with new leadership in Israel. Time will tell.
Beyond increased funding for security systems for synagogues, Jewish schools, and community centres, no one seems to know what to do to seriously combat antisemitism. Many are sincerely empathetic, but few are willing to name the root causes out loud. If we can’t name it, we can’t fix it. And fewer still are able to think creatively about how to get at the heart of the matter. And then we met Senator David Arnot. You likely have not heard of him nor of his report, which got little attention when it came out last April. Senator Arnot of Saskatchewan chairs the Senate’s Human Rights Committee, which produced “Standing United Against Antisemitism: Protecting Communities and Strengthening Canadian Democracy.” Its title alone is significant. It clarifies that antisemitism is a threat to democracy. This is a fact of history that too few understand. Among its twenty-two recommendations, the report calls for educational curricula to be built into all Canadian school systems from kindergarten through Grade 12. Senator Arnot confronted anti-Indigenous discrimination in his province with a serious and consistent educational approach. Within a decade, they saw a marked and measurable change. Based on that success, Arnot believes education is the key to combatting antisemitism, too. As students of history, we know that antisemitism cannot be eradicated altogether, but it can be contained and reduced to whispers in dark corners underground. Barricades and bollards can protect from some kinds of harm, but they cannot change how people think or feel or what they value.

On behalf of the group of rabbis, I thanked Senator Arnot for his leadership and moral courage. I presented him with a gift copy of Rabbi W. Gunter Plaut’s Torah Commentary. As a young man, Plaut earned a law degree in Berlin. After fleeing Nazi Europe, becoming a rabbi, and returning as a chaplain in the American Army, he devoted much of his rabbinate to civil rights. He served as the Vice Chair of the Human Rights Committee of Ontario and in the mid-1980’s was tasked with helping to redesign Canada’s approach to immigration and refugee relief. The capstone project of his life was writing the Torah Commentary. Rabbi Plaut believed that physical protections were necessary, but not enough. Education and moral clarity were also essential. Senator Arnot knew of Rabbi Plaut and was visibly moved to receive a sacred gift bearing his name.
When I asked Senator Arnot who is championing his report in government, he answered: “No one.” This is the harder work. Getting to the root causes of Canadian antisemitism and addressing them will take a generation, so there is urgency to begin now. Let’s take comfort in knowing there are people like Senator Arnot turning their good minds to creatively addressing the alarming rise of antisemitism in our country. Let’s commit to amplifying their voices and pledging to be their partners. In the coming weeks and months, there will be more to share through the work of our Advocacy Committee and our Interfaith Committee. I hope you will join us, as the anthem goes: “True patriot love in all of us command.”
Shabbat Shalom.




Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!